Q&A: Seniors and Increased Maintenance

Q I live in a co-op in the Lower East of Manhattan. We have an entrenched board, which is under the control of our building manager. Over the past few years, our building has made some ‘improvements’ to the tiles, windows, lobby, etc. that have all been very costly. There are many seniors in the co-op, and we suspect that the board and our manager are planning large increases in maintenance fees. Being on fixed incomes, any large increases will probably end up in our eviction. Is there anything we can do to protect ourselves?

—Concerned Senior

A “You, dear reader, are an owner of a valuable apartment in New York City. Therefore, the government is not so inclined to assist you, as it does for certain renters of rent-regulated apartments, aged 62 and older, by providing a senior citizens rent increase exemption (SCRIE),” says attorney Deborah Koplovitz, of the Manhattan-based law firm of Rosen & Livingston. “As there are no governmental regulations restricting the amounts of maintenance increases a private corporation can charge, my advice is not just to protect yourself, but to ‘empower yourself.’ The only way you can truly control the amount of maintenance you pay is to run for, and be elected to, the board.

“Retirees on fixed incomes have concerns about cost of living increases, to be sure, but you also have a distinct advantage over those of us still in the work force; you own more of the precious commodity of time. You have time to serve on the board of directors once elected, but, more importantly, you have the time to solicit votes to get elected to the board in the first place. Once elected, you can then determine the kinds of capital improvements your co-op makes, and the amount of maintenance paid by shareholders.

“Though the overwhelming portion of maintenance fees are fixed, there are a few creative ways boards can work to try to normalize maintenance costs. For example, governmental incentives, such as the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA) program relating to energy, can significantly assist a coop in lowering its energy costs. This may, in turn help to cap maintenance increases, as many coops have recently faced double-digit maintenance increases due mostly to the higher cost of oil. The NYSERDA program provides not only low costs loans but valuable cash incentives in exchange for increasing energy efficiency and making your building more ‘green.’

“Finally, if you are really in a bind, and do not care to run for the board of directors, you could consider taking out a reverse mortgage with a lender to help you meet your monthly maintenance costs.”

Related Articles

Small Business Jobs Survival Act Sows Division at City Hall

Council Holds Public Hearing on Much-Debated Bill

Withholding Your Maintenance Payments

Do You Have a Right to Do That During a Dispute?

Q&A: Shared Sewer Line

Q&A: Shared Sewer Line



  • Boy, , the above is truly NOT helpful. Because we are owners of an apartment doesn;t mean that we have fat bank accounts or whatever. You have to be on welfare (not contributing anything financially to society) to get FREE help for anything.
  • I'm 88 and live in a studio in a Michel Lama coop. My income (Social Security and a small pension) is $25,000 a year. My son has moved in with me. His income is $8,000 a year. My maintenance charge was $620 a month and the new maintenance charge will be over $800 a month. Can you help me to get this figure reduced. I certainly would appreciate it. On my son's income he can't help with the increased charge.
  • That is dumb, there are no reverse mortgages for co-ops.
  • Are there subsidies that can help shareholders pay their my monthly maintenance, when shareholders monthly fixed income is lower than the monthly
  • Good luck trying to find a lending institution that funds reverse mortgages of co-ops.
  • Like it’s so easy to join the board. Our shareholders never seem to be interested enough to attend meetings or vote by proxy, so consequently there’s never enough to form a quorum to even allow a vote. What do you do about that?
  • As an owner of a NYC coop, a former board President in another building and In real estate sales I truly empathize with other owners. The only way to make a difference is to get yourself and likeminded individuals on the board. You may have to promote yourself or get enough proxies In order to do a hostile board takeover. However costs have risen and all are facing the same issue. Most boards will not approve reverse mortgages, even if you find a lender. If your coop is worth enough you can sell and pay rent. Of course rent will be high but if you manage the funds of your sale correctly it may be more than enough to last you the remainder of your life.
  • Or sell and move to Kansas
  • Hello I live in Cooperative building in Brooklyn , Kings Bay Area. I am a widow , seniors citizen , 71 yrs old. My maintenance is $700. Very difficult to afford now. How is decrease my maintenance? Please , let me know