Q&A: Litigious Neighbors

Q. What should you do as an owner if you know of a small subset of owners in your condo that keep bringing coordinated and meritless legal actions, and even make public postings about your building that could harm your own valuation? Are there any actions you can take? 

                                 —Sick of the Suits

A. Dov Treiman, managing partner at Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C., in Manhattan, says, “There is very little a condo unit owner can do to get relief from other unit owners who bring meritless legal actions and make improper public postings. The board of managers may possibly have the power under the governing documents of the condo to impose fines and even to foreclose on them or even to collect its attorneys fees for defending the meritless actions. However, unit owners do not have the power to force the board to do that. In some jurisdictions, there are procedures in the courts that allow for someone who is being hurt by meritless actions to ask the court to impose its own fines on the improper plaintiffs or even to require that before any further suits be filed, they first have to be checked for potential merit by a judge. This latter, while useful, is extremely rare. In extreme circumstances, an aggrieved unit owner can sue the troublemakers for reducing the value of the aggrieved unit owner’s unit. However, none of the procedures outlined in this answer would be wisely undertaken without the assistance of a very experienced lawyer.

“In New York, there are other procedures that are available for a co-op, but your question was about condos.”

Related Articles

Attention Board Members: Case Law Update

Board Actions Upheld in Recent Objectionable Conduct Ruling

Revisiting Levandusky

A Seminal Co-op Case Still Holds Sway

Q&A: Neighbor’s Annoying Bed Bug Problem

Q&A: Neighbor’s Annoying Bed Bug Problem

Q&A: Disturbing Neighbors

Q&A: Disturbing Neighbors

Developer Sued for Stiffing Neighbors

Embattled Mountbatten Exec Owes Condo 600k+ in Fees & Fines

Dealing With Disruptive Residents

Empathy & Education vs. Enforcement & Eviction