Q&A: Bed Bug Dilemma Q&A

Q “I am the superintendent of a Manhattan cooperative. One shareholder's apartment has bed bugs and the board had done the right thing by paying the exterminator bills as this is no time to be having an argument as to who is responsible to pay. However, six months later and three different companies—including two of the major players in the industry—the bed bugs remain.”

So my questions are:

1.Who is legally responsible to foot the cost?

2. As the shareholder still resides here and their apartment is still fully furnished, in my point of view it will be very difficult to treat this apartment correctly. What is the legal route to take here? Can the board force the shareholder to move their belongings out to a fumigation holding facility, and who pays for that?

3. The building does not have full control (yet they are paying) over how extensive a treatment is given as the shareholder lives there and they are making decisions and choices as what to throw away and what to keep etc. What is the legal standpoint here?

-Frustrated Super

A “Under §78(1) of the New York Multiple Dwelling Law, landlords are responsible for maintaining their premises in good repair,” says attorney Mia D. Falls, a litigation associate with the New York office of the law firm Norris McLaughlin & Marcus, P.A. “In addition, the implied warranty of habitability set forth in New York Real Property Law §235-b obligates a landlord to warrant that an apartment is habitable and in a condition that does not adversely affect a tenant’s health and safety. Both statutes are applicable to cooperative apartments.

“Recent Housing Court and Civil Court cases have relied on these statutes in holding landlords responsible for failing to properly address bedbug infestations by giving an abatement or awarding damages for property loss that is the direct result of a landlord’s failure to properly address a bedbug infestation. Further, in October 2009, the New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development (“HPD”) issued a memorandum to the managing agents, site managers and boards of directors of cooperatives under its supervision. Pursuant to the memorandum, HPD requires cooperatives to assume the responsibility for eliminating bedbug infestations. Therefore, considering the current landscape, all landlords should assume responsibility for exterminating bedbugs in their buildings, including infestations in cooperators’ apartments.

“If after successive bedbug treatments an exterminator is unable to completely eradicate the bedbugs in a particular apartment, it is important to determine why the extermination treatments have failed. This may require an affidavit from the exterminator treating the apartment and possibly an affidavit from an independent expert. If treatment does not work because the cooperator failed to properly prepare the apartment according to the exterminator’s instructions or because the cooperator failed to dispose of infested belongings pursuant to the exterminator’s directives, the cooperative would have a basis for charging the continuing extermination costs to the cooperator. The cooperative could then commence an action against the offending cooperator to recover these fees, provided the cooperative can obtain convincing evidence that the additional extermination costs are due to the cooperator’s conduct.

“In dealing with a non-compliant cooperator, it is important to work with the cooperative’s attorneys, who will be familiar with the cooperative’s governing documents and current case law, in order to develop an appropriate strategy.”

Related Articles

Managing Hoarding Disorder - FREE Virtual Workshop

Wednesday, May 25 from 7-9pm

Q&A: Neighbor’s Annoying Bed Bug Problem

Q&A: Neighbor’s Annoying Bed Bug Problem

Multifamily Bird Control

Coping With Feathered Pests

Flood Risk Rises for Condos & Co-ops

How to be Physically & Financially Ready

Q&A: Damages Over Parking

Q&A: Damages Over Parking

Seasonal Pests

COVID Complicates - But Doesn't Eliminate - the Need for Pest Control

 

7 Comments

  • At the very least, it's time to consider some alternatives to whatever extermination methods you've tried so far, such as heat treatment. This gets around the question of what to discard. You might also consider bringing in a detection dog to try and identify exactly where bugs are harboring. All it takes is one egg sac left behind some place and the nightmare begins all over again!
  • what aabout garden aprtments in a coop and not knowing who has besides a family and how to get management to take responsibilty . what affidavit has to be made out by exterminator. trying to find law passed by patterson about coops and managment.
  • I would like to know what is a reasonable length of time for the treatment of bedbugs in a cooperative apartment building from the time the management company is notified to the treatment of the apartments?
  • Vacuum your carpets with podwer which kills bedbugs and dust mites easy to find.Clean floors ..Vacuum and clean sofasBedrooms ..You can "bomb" the place for a quick fix BUT cover foodstuffs, Cd's, computer ..Please don't forget to take the dog, cat, hamster ..with you!Wait for at least 24 hours before returning and then open all windows and turn on all bathroom/kitchen fans to ventilate.Then get a cover non-plastic for dust mites to go over your mattress and one over your box spring. Usually 80 bucks for a queen and 40 bucks for box spring. Get covers for bed pillows as well.Wash all bed linen at least once a week in HOT water. Try not to use wool blankets since you can't toss them into the washer.The key to bed bugs is personal hygiene cleanliness and household cleanliness.References : BCL
  • does the co-op pay the exterminator or does the cooperator living there have to pay?
  • who is responsible for bed bugs in a condo the owner or the management
  • I am the President of our Condo. WE have a unit owner who has bed bugs but refuses to do anything about it. He threatens criminal action if we force ouselves in the unit which is extremel cluttered. They have all sorts of remedies for coops , landlord , tenant, what about unit owners who refuse to do anything, what course of action can the Boad and management take. He claims he has no bed bugs but our exterminator says otherwise.