Q&A: Another COVID-Canceled Meeting

Q. Our annual shareholder meeting is to be held each April (per our bylaws). However, when COVID started in March 2020, our 2020 annual meeting was canceled and we have not had one since. The last meeting was held in April 2019.  When I’ve contacted our board of directors and management company asking when one will be held or scheduled, they keep telling me that they can’t hold one at this time. I don’t understand why and when I attempt to reach them for more information, they refuse to respond to my requests. Do you know what I can do or who I can contact that would be able to have the authority to make our board schedule a meeting, either in person or via Zoom? Our bylaws state this is a must, and as shareholders we want and deserve this to happen. 

Is there someone who has power over our BODs? Should I be submitting a complaint with the Bureau of Consumer Protection in the Office of the Attorney General?  

                                            —Feeling Ignored 

A. “There is no excuse for not holding an annual shareholders meeting, which is a crucial component of ensuring shareholder democracy in a cooperative corporation by electing directors and holding the board of directors accountable,” says Slava Hazin, partner in New York City law firm Warshaw Burstein. “In the first instance, the New York Business Corporation Law (BCL) permits corporations, including cooperative housing corporations, to conduct board actions electronically and to hold virtual shareholder meetings. During the pandemic, Governor Cuomo issued an Executive Order that suspended the requirement of having in-person shareholder meetings. In April 2021, the New York Legislature amended the BCL to permit virtual shareholder meetings, with an expiration date of December 31, 2021. However, in November 2021, Governor Hochul signed a law making this change permanent. Thus, if the board and the managing agent do not want to hold an in-person meeting so as to prevent the spread of the COVID virus, they have the option of conducting a virtual meeting. Second, Section 602 of the BCL requires annual meetings. In the event that the board does not hold an annual meeting, both New York law and your cooperative’s bylaws provide for a special meeting of shareholders that may be called by either the board, a person authorized to do so by the bylaws, or by a certain percentage of the shareholders. You should have an attorney review your cooperative’s bylaws on how a special meeting may be called by shareholders and follow those procedures if the board continues to ignore your demand.”  

Related Articles

Q&A: Meeting, Please?

Q&A: Meeting, Please?

Q&A: Where’s Our Meeting?

Q&A: Where’s Our Meeting?

Q&A: Guidelines Are Just Guidelines

Q&A: Guidelines Are Just Guidelines

Virtual Governance

How Co-ops & Condos Hold Meetings Distantly

Q&A: This Board’s Gone to the Dogs

Q&A: This Board’s Gone to the Dogs

‘Pandemic Pets’ in Multifamily Communities

Rules vs. Reasonable Accommodation

 

Comments

  • In the first instance the Governor bent to high interest groups in relation to the virtual shareholders meetings; it is well know by now that the interaction between shareholders and the board members are extremely limited, in-depth discussion and getting straight answers on relevant matters is curtailed by so-called time constraints, there is no set/uniform procedure on how voting must/will be conducted, shareholders mike are cutoff at the whim of an appointed unknown controller, there are self-appointed voting inspectors, and the vote counting process is open to falsification., just to name a few. Secondly, the easy reference used is the BCL, which is not enforced by any regulatory agency but is left to the shareholders to obtain their own legal representation from out of their pockets - while the board have the use of the corporation's attorney which is paid for by all the shareholders. attorneys is appears are reluctant to change and include provisions into the occupancy agreement and by-laws that would provide for addition measures to force boards to be accountable, examples are what is referred to as special meetings, providing access to corporation records that can expose misuse of 'power'.