Chelsea Condo Owners Halt Tower Project by Paying $11M They Bought the Air Rights to Protect Their Views

Chelsea Condo Owners Halt Tower Project by Paying $11M
Chelsea street (photo: GK tramrunner229, via WikiMedia Commons)

A group of residents from a Chelsea condo took an unusual approach to protect their views from being blocked by a proposed neighboring residential tower that developer Extell wanted to build.

Rather than suing, the condo owners paid Extell $11 million for the air rights, The New York Times reported on Monday.

Extell had proposed constructing a 145-foot condo tower to replace a set of smaller buildings it acquired in 2016.

Concerned that the proposed tower would block their views, including the Empire State Building, the group from the L-shaped Chelsea condo made an offer of $11 million to buy the air rights from Extell. The company's founder, Gary Barnett, had originally wanted more than that price. 

After further negotiations, both parties arrived at a deal.

John Muse, an absentee owner whose children reside in the building, told the Times: “It was expensive. I wouldn't say prohibitively. But expensive.”

As the article pointed out, not all of the owners from the Chelsea condo building paid the same amount in their offer to Extell. Those who lived on the lower floors either paid less or nothing.

Even Barnett admitted that this type of deal was uncommon; usually it's the developer who pays for the air rights. “Most of the time, they sue you and try and stop you somehow,” he told the Times. “These people stepped up to the plate and paid market value for the building rights.”

Instead, the developer constructed a small retail cube on the site, reported Curbed.

David Chiu is an associate editor at The Cooperator.


Related Articles

Study: NY Metro Millennials Paying More for Homes

Study: NY Metro Millennials Paying More for Homes

Financial Barriers to Homeownership Mount for the Age Group

NYC Sees 8.8% Decline in Housing Inventory

NYC Sees 8.8% Decline in Housing Inventory

Shortage Predates the Pandemic

Real estate prices have grown exponentially, Vector illustration design concept in flat style

Challenges for Rental Conversions in NY and NJ

Affordable Housing vs. the Overheated Market