Court Foils Attempt to Block Corporate Transparency Act CAI’s Motion Denied

Judge gavel on the table with blurry books in the background

The Background

In a recent case, the Community Associations Institute (CAI) and several community associations sought a preliminary injunction against the enforcement of the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA). The CAI argued that requiring their members to disclose “beneficial owners” to the Treasury Department was unlawful, violated the Administrative Procedure Act, exceeded Congress’s authority, and violated the First and Fourth Amendments. Read the full case here.

The Decision

The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia denied the CAI’s motion for a preliminary injunction, finding that the CAI was unlikely to succeed on the merits of their claims. The court held that the CTA’s definition of “reporting company” clearly included community associations and that the act did not violate the CAI’s First or Fourth Amendment rights.   

The Implications

This decision is a significant setback for community associations seeking to avoid compliance with the CTA. Community associations such as condominium associations, cooperative associations, and homeowners associations (HOAs) are required to file reports with the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) disclosing their “beneficial owners” as defined under the CTA.   

What This Means for Property Managers

Property managers must ensure that the communities they manage comply with the CTA by the end of the year. Failure to comply could result in significant financial penalties of up to $591 per day starting January 1, 2025.   

Don't Risk Non-compliance

Ballotmanagement.com offers a solution to help property managers comply with the CTA. The application easily allows for the collection of necessary information from board members, generate the required reports, and files them with FinCEN systematically. Ballot Management can set up all of management’s associations on the application quickly and compliance is then very easy for management and its boards. Whenever changes need to be made (for example, a board member changes or the information a board member submits for themselves changes), they can be done right in Ballot Management and an update report send systematically to FinCEN so that the association and it management company are in compliance and no penalties will be assessed.

Related Articles

Business man hand change wooden cube block with TRUST and TRUTH business word on table background. Trustworthy, faith, beliefs and honesty concept

Corporate Transparency Act (CTA) Compliance

Condos, Co-ops, HOAs Likely Must Register—or Face Steep Fines

2024 NY Spring Expo Seminar: Resident Rights vs. Board Confidentiality – New Standards for Access to Records & Disclosure of Private Information

2024 NY Spring Expo Seminar: Resident Rights vs. Board Confidentiality – New Standards for Access to Records & Disclosure of Private Information

Sponsored by: Smith, Buss & Jacobs LLP

The Cooperator Events presents: Co-op and Condo Law Compliance - Tips For Safety, Efficiency, & Avoiding Fines

The Cooperator Events presents: Co-op and Condo Law Compliance - Tips For Safety, Efficiency, & Avoiding Fines

A Virtual Town Hall Sponsored by Czarnowski & Beer LLP

Personal mental protect. Self boundaries capsule, person ignored people crowd and communication. Protection and recover health, insocial vector character. Illustration of personal mental protection

Boards & Boundaries

How ‘Available’ Should You Be?

Wooden figurine as person who have questions and need help solving the problems among crowd people. Man has no idea on wood table. Business marketing and Creative solution concept.

Q&A: Contacting the Board

Q&A: Contacting the Board

Businessman working on laptop computer with electronics document icons, E-document management, online documentation database, paperless office concept

Q&A: A Window Into the Records

Q&A: A Window Into the Records

 

Comments

  • While the Virginia Court did not nullify the CTA,the exact terms and aims of the CTA must be taken into account. A board member who is one of possibly hundreds of shareholders with a fractional interest in the corporation, and, more often than not, a short one or two year term, along with a number of other members. This means that there is no degree of control as in a closely held corporation controlled by one, maybe two or three people. These old-timey co-op arrangements are not the target of the CTA, which is looking to disclose money-launderers, illegal activity or tax evasion.