How Legal is That Doggy in the Window Understanding the New York CIty Pet Law

Ever wonder how that frisky pug got the penthouse window seat in a "pet-free" building? Or how that tabby from 4C manages to saunter down the hall like he owns the place? Thanks to New York City's "pet law," many co-op and condo owners have found a way to keep a pet or two despite their building's otherwise anti-pet policy.

Snips and Snails and"¦Legislation

Established in 1983, the law was originally created in response to disputes arising between landlords and rental tenants. In these cases, landlords who had looked the other way for years when it came to their tenants' cats and dogs were suddenly evicting these same people for breaking no-pets rules. As one might expect, these evictions were happening as the housing market grew tight and apartments became more valuable. In short, the evictions were likely taking place simply to free up space that could be rented for more money. In an effort to stem these types of evictions, the New York City pet law was passed.

With those circumstances in mind, it's easy to see how the law developed into its present form. In basic terms, the New York City pet law states that residents living in buildings with more than three units may keep a pet in a no-pet building if that animal has been kept "openly and notoriously" for three months or more.

Unfortunately, "open and notorious" is not nearly as scintillating as it sounds. It simply means that if you live in a building and own a dog, the porter need only see your dog once and fail to report it for the law to kick into effect. Even if a board member sees it four months later, it won't count because another building employee - the porter - already knows of its existence. "It doesn't have to be so open and notorious," says attorney Doug Heller of the Manhattan law firm of Friedman Krauss & Zlotolow. "Someone just has to see it."

Manhattan-based attorney Karen Copeland says some interpretations are even looser, especially in the case of animals that don't usually leave the premises, such as cats or small, litter-trained dogs. With a cat, it's difficult to argue that someone must have seen it because it gets walked through the lobby every day. It's a very rare cat that ever leaves its home. This is when some of the more lax interpretations of the law come into play. Simply leaving the food bowls and cat toys out when the superintendent comes to visit the apartment may be enough to meet the "open and notorious" requirement. "Some residents will take snapshots of their cats in the window to prove they're visible from the street," Copeland says.


Related Articles

‘Pandemic Pets’ in Multifamily Communities

Rules vs. Reasonable Accommodation

You’re Quarantining. What About Your Dog?

Factoring Pets Into Coronavirus Considerations

Q&A: When Does “No Pets” Mean No Pets?

Q&A: When Does “No Pets” Mean No Pets?

Securing Air Quality in the COVID-19 Era

HVAC, HEPA Filters, & UV Disinfection

Your Pet Policy vs. NYC's Human Rights Commission

New Guidance Requires 'Cooperative Dialogue'

Q&A: Carrying Dogs Through the Building's Front Door?

Q&A: Carrying Dogs Through the Building's Front Door?



  • What's disappointing about this article and so many of a similar type in this and other publications, is that some people chose to move into a building that is dog free because they themselves may have dog-related allergies or psychological issues. Then when someone wants a dog and simply gets a doctor to write a "needs" issue for that person, all rights seem to "go to the dogs". When there is a true need, of course companion dogs should be allowed. But Ms. Lent and most of your other writers always seem to go soft and fuzzy and side with dog owners/lovers, making the rest of us out to be crass, heartless idiots. For them, any kind of restrictions about dogs being in a building are made to sound inane.
  • Hi, I live in a no dog apartment cats are aloud. But I have many over the years. I don't wanna move because this is a expensive apartment and I'm paying low price for what it is. I don't know what to do. I have lived here for 7 to 8 years. Can I use something's against them. For example, I have tons of things in my apartment I asked to fix and they never do. Can I use that against them if I get a dog and they try to evict me? I'm trying to find my lease to make sure they don't allow dogs. I dout it though. Since there was a women for lived in the apartment as me and had a dog and they continued to raise her rent more and more intill she couldn't pay for it. So she moved. So please give me some loopholes that 50/50 chances thanks.
  • What about people who are in supportive/ mental housing or other programs do the same open and notorious rules still apply? We've had our 4 cats for over a year with building staff know we had them is there anything we can do to keep from relinquishing our animals?
  • Why do you think you should move into a building that has a no pet policy and have the right to break the policy. That is rude and you knew the rules in advance so move into a building that agrees to pets. Stop coming up with ways to break the policy when people have real allergies and phobias.